Welders and inspector reviewing welding documents on a welding table
Facts & Know-how

WPS, WPQR and welder qualification: what is the difference?

WPS, pWPS, WPQR and welder certificate are often confused. We explain the terms and when you need which one.

PublishedAbout 4 minutes reading time

The terms at a glance

Anyone dealing with certified welding work soon hears abbreviations such as WPS, pWPS and WPQR. They are often used interchangeably, yet each records something different. In this article we explain the terms and when you need which one.

In short: the WPS describes how to weld, the WPQR proves that the procedure works, and the welder certificate proves that the welder can do it.

Laptop with Sombroek W.E. welding records next to a welding table
Welding data and test results are recorded in the WPQR.
DocumentWhat does it record?Standard
pWPSA proposed welding procedure, not yet provenISO 15609-1
WPQRThe qualification record: the test piece and the test resultsISO 15614-1 or another route from ISO 15607
WPSThe approved welding instruction for the shop floorISO 15609-1
Welder certificateProof that the welder can weld to a WPSISO 9606-1

WPS: the recipe for the weld

A WPS (Welding Procedure Specification) is the work instruction for the welder. It contains all the variables that determine weld quality: parent metal and thickness, welding process, filler metal, shielding gas, welding position, joint preparation, current and voltage, preheat and interpass temperature, and run sequence. For arc welding, the content of a WPS is described in ISO 15609-1.

A WPS can only be used in production once it has been qualified. For that you need a WPQR.

From pWPS to WPQR: the proof

You start with a pWPS: a preliminary WPS. A test piece is welded to that pWPS and then examined extensively, for example by visual inspection, radiographic or ultrasonic testing, tensile and bend tests, impact tests, hardness tests and macro examination. If the results are good, they are recorded in a WPQR (Welding Procedure Qualification Record). On that basis you draw up one or more WPSs within the range of qualification.

The best-known route is a welding procedure test to ISO 15614-1. ISO 15607 also lists other routes, such as tested welding consumables (ISO 15610), previous welding experience (ISO 15611), a standard welding procedure (ISO 15612) and a pre-production welding test (ISO 15613). These alternatives have a more limited scope. Whether you may use them depends on the application standard or the contract.

Welder qualification: can the welder do it?

A qualified welding procedure says nothing about the welder’s skill. That is what welder qualification is for; for steel, it is done to ISO 9606-1. The welder welds a test piece to a WPS under the supervision of an examiner. The certificate states exactly what the welder is qualified for: the process, the type of weld, the filler metal group, the thickness, the diameter and the position.

The key difference: a welding procedure qualification is about the method, a welder qualification is about the person. A welder who successfully welds the test piece for a welding procedure test can, under certain conditions, also be qualified for the corresponding range. Operators of mechanised and automatic welding equipment are covered by a separate standard: ISO 14732.

Marnix Sombroek at a welding table with test pieces and documents
Test pieces and documentation are assessed together.

What does EN 1090 require?

For steel structures to EN 1090-2, much depends on the execution class (EXC). From EXC2 upwards, welding must be carried out with qualified welding procedures and welding coordination must be in place. Welders must be qualified to ISO 9606-1. The quality system for welding follows ISO 3834: part 4 for EXC1, part 3 for EXC2 and part 2 for EXC3 and EXC4.

Common misconceptions

  • “My welders are certified, so my welding procedures are too.” No, these are two separate qualifications.
  • “A WPQR is the same as a WPS.” No, the WPQR is the proof; the WPS is the instruction for the shop floor.
  • “One WPQR covers everything.” A WPQR has a range of qualification. Outside it, for example with a different material group, a larger thickness range or a different process, you need a new qualification.
  • “A welder certificate is valid indefinitely.” No, it must be confirmed every 6 months and revalidated periodically. Read more in how long is your welding certificate valid?
Qualifying welding procedures or welders?Sombroek W.E. supervises welding procedure qualifications (WPQR) and conducts welding tests to ISO 9606-1, in our welding booth in Heerhugowaard or at your location. You receive a reply within 24 hours.
Sombroek Welding Engineering Marnix Sombroek of Sombroek W.E.
Written by

Marnix Sombroek

Specialist in welding coordination, weld inspection and welder qualifications

  • IWT
  • IWI-C
  • VT-3

Marnix is your point of contact at Sombroek W.E. for questions about welding technology, inspection and qualifications. In this article he connects the requirements of the standard with the choices you make in the workshop. For advice on your situation, always discuss your work, certificate and project requirements.

Published
Last updated

Sources and accountability

  1. TWI: welding procedure approval and alternative routes.
  2. TWI: difference between procedure and welder qualification.
  3. TWI: CE marking, EN 1090 and ISO 3834.

This explanation is general and does not replace the standard. The applicable edition of the standard, your certificate and the project requirements are decisive.

The specialisms and qualifications mentioned correspond to the company information of Sombroek W.E. Source links marked ↗ open in a new tab.